I made the following post on the Car and Driver Forum in regards to the BMW 330i beating the Lexus IS350. I wonder what the responses will be like.
Crester On The Car & Driver Forum said:BMW Wins $35,000 Sport Sedan Comparison
After reading the $35K Sport Sedan comparison... I must really wonder what Car & Driver is doing. Firstly... how could the BMW 3-series win when it had numerous critical problems with the car? How can a car spin out of control during a brake test because of an ABS system failure, fail to start numerous times during the test, have A/C malfunction, etc. and STILL win the competition???
And that brings me to another point the BMW didn't actually "win" the competition. If you add up the numbers, there is a mistake in the BMW's column. Infact the ACTUAL total for the BMW is 212... which ties it with the Lexus IS350! In this situation the Lexus should obviously win since firstly it did not break down during the test, and secondly it is a better car overall.